Tuesday 5 March 2013

Big-O notation: Care on asymptotic behaviour

Big-O notation conveys us information about how a given algorithm run time scales with respect to a given input size.  However, one has to be careful on the interpretation of this scaling (limiting) behaviour. First of all, when we talk about $O(N^2)$, it doesn't mean that it is valid for any input size. Let's  illustrate that asymptotic behaviour shown by big-O notation could be “misleading” for “smaller” input. Let’s take number of operation $T(N)=4 N^2 – 2N$. $T’(4)$ must be 4 times of $T’(2)$ if we consider as $T’(N) = N^2$. But if we use $T(N)$ instead, $T(4)$ would be $4.666667$ times of $T(2)$.

A good example in this direction  is N-body force calculations (or here). An $O(N^2)$ algorithm performs better compare to $O(NlogN)$ ones up to a break-even point even 50K particles. This is a good paper explaining this;
Pringle, Gavin J. "Comparison of an O (N) and an O (N log N) N-body solver."
(c) Copyright 2008-2024 Mehmet Suzen (suzen at acm dot org)

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License